Any known problems with X-Trail Diesels?

Hally · 27-04-2012, 06:25 AM

Hi All,

I am looking to order a new car in the next few weeks. Until recently I had my mind made up that I was going to get a new Jeep Grand Cherokee (3.0L Turbp Dieasel) but a mate suggested I drive an X-Trail diesel. I duly did and must say I quite enjoyed it and am now seriously considering a TL with a 6 speed manual.

I don't know much about current Nissan diesels, so am just throwing it out there. Is there any known issues with this motor or car? Any advice appreciated.

Cheers,

Hally

midnightXR6 · 27-04-2012, 06:35 AM

20012-2007 UK model

112bhp 2.2 diesels, listen for timing chain/tensioner rattles and check for losing power. Noticeable between 1,500 and 2,000rpm.
The Rattling timing chains were caused by fracture of the timing chain guides inside the chain cover on some but not all 112bhp

2.2 litre diesels. May also see white smoke. Seizing of diesel pump due to lack of lubricity in the fuel can snap the chains of all 2.2 diesels.

Injector and ECU problems on 2.2 136s. Turbo failures on 136PS 2.2i diesel, possibly because drivers are not letting them spool down by idling the engine for a minute or two from red hot which is what nissan used to get out of warranty work .

TSB to replace failing 'Power Boost Sensors' that can also lead to turbo failure.

I cant say for the new 07 onwards model but would avoid any diesel xtrail or navara of same age.

I would opt for the petrol version if you can.

Plenty diesel ones for sale over here with buggered engines and low miles

Hally · 27-04-2012, 06:55 AM

Hi Midnight,

i just notice your from Aberdeen. my family is from Banchory, just down the road.

Thanks for the info. I am buying brand new and will likely only have the car for a period of 12 months outside of factory warranty. The diesel we have in the X=Trail here is 2.0 and is 127kw/360NM. Was thinking it may have come from Renault?

midnightXR6 · 27-04-2012, 07:17 AM

Small world mate. I work in Aberdeen but im from Falkirk.

The 2.2DCI was renault hence why it was crap. I dont really know much about the newer ones as.

SumoDog68 · 27-04-2012, 07:41 AM

Renault only makes some great F1 engines - must be crap :-)
UK market had YD series 2.2 Turbo Diesel , aussie market gets M9R Renault engine which is a benchmark for 2l turbodiesels. They are offered in two tunes - less power and torque for auto version.

Nic85 · 27-04-2012, 07:53 AM

Can I suggest you go and have a look/drive of a Mitsubishi ASX Aspire diesel? Similar size and features, but about $7k cheaper. Slightly smaller diesel (1.8L - 110kW/300Nm) but it's also over 100kgs lighter.

I'll bet the Mitsubishi will drive much better than the Nissan. Worth a look for sure.

SumoDog68 · 27-04-2012, 08:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nic85

Can I suggest you go and have a look/drive of a Mitsubishi ASX Aspire diesel? Similar size and features, but about $7k cheaper. Slightly smaller diesel (1.8L - 110kW/300Nm) but it's also over 100kgs lighter.

I'll bet the Mitsubishi will drive much better than the Nissan. Worth a look for sure.

ASX is one size smaller then XTrail - in this case you would lose your bet :-)

Hally · 27-04-2012, 08:50 AM

Nic85,

I have driven the ASX (in diesel). We have one in our fleet at work. Drives nice but is a bit t small for what I want, plus not sure if I could get one in an manual?

If i go for an x-Trail it will be the manual, with the higher level of tune.

For $42,500 drive away they have a lot of kit included.

midnightXR6 · 27-04-2012, 07:55 AM

Didnt say anything about F1 ;)

Nic85 · 27-04-2012, 02:15 PM

Sumodog: I'd suggest you go and drive both of them back to back. There is quite a difference.

Hally: If you've driven the ASX for work, then you'd know they come in manual (6 speed) ONLY.

The X-Trail is a foot longer and 3 inches higher than the ASX. The ASX is one of the most fuel efficient SUV's available (second only to the Mazda CX-5 diesel) and can be had for around $37k drive away.

I'd suggest you have a look at one to see if they suit your needs. If it's too small, then at least you've covered all options!

If you can do without the manual, I would suggest looking at a Hyundai ix35 too.

4.0i OHC · 27-04-2012, 03:18 PM

I'd personally overlook the X-Trail and go for the Skoda Yeti TDI manual instead if you're looking for a fun to drive SUV.

SumoDog68 · 27-04-2012, 06:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nic85

Sumodog: I'd suggest you go and drive both of them back to back. There is quite a difference.

Hally: If you've driven the ASX for work, then you'd know they come in manual (6 speed) ONLY.

The X-Trail is a foot longer and 3 inches higher than the ASX. The ASX is one of the most fuel efficient SUV's available (second only to the Mazda CX-5 diesel) and can be had for around $37k drive away.

I'd suggest you have a look at one to see if they suit your needs. If it's too small, then at least you've covered all options!

If you can do without the manual, I would suggest looking at a Hyundai ix35 too.

There is definately a difference - having said that i actually prefer X-Trail - ASX ride is not to my taste - too harsh on our bumpy roads. I 've got dogs and ride MTB - X-Trail is spaceous and practical enough ASX is not .
It comes down to what do
you want from a car.

SirHenry · 27-04-2012, 07:21 PM

Another suggestion if you didn't mind the Xtrail is the Renault Koleos it's pretty much a Renault X Trail (co developed with it's 30% partner Nissan).

The petrol version has Nissan's bulletproof 2.5L engine and according to one review I read is mated to one of the best cvt transmissions they have seen.

Plus if you go for the 4x4 it also has the easy click switch.

My wife's had one for the past year and what a fantastic car to drive. All of the Nissan engine and drive train with Renault's attention to detail.

Just an alternative suggestion, plus the used ones are quite cheap and low kms.

Hally · 27-04-2012, 07:52 PM

Nic85 - Our fleet one at work is definately an auto, so it it mustn't be a deisel. I will check it again. We have about 8 different cars for staff to use so I might of mixed it up with one of the others.

I am really suprised that thee is only 3 inches difference in height.

SirHenry - I drove a Koleos a couple of years ago, and whilst ok it didn't do much or me. I really want a deisel/manual combination on the X-Trail size vehicle. On something like the Jeep or even Territory size I now I have no choice.

At then end of the day I don't need full 4wd capability (low range etc), I just want a high ridung wagon that gives me a bit more practicallity than my current sedan so I am open to options.

Nic85 · 28-04-2012, 07:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SumoDog68

There is definately a difference - having said that i actually prefer X-Trail - ASX ride is not to my taste - too harsh on our bumpy roads. I 've got dogs and ride MTB - X-Trail is spaceous and practical enough ASX is not .
It comes down to what do
you want from a car.

This line lends me to believe you haven't driven an ASX. They're very soft riding and very comfortable over bumps. They ride a lot softer than Tiguan, SX4, CX7 and ix35, to name a few. The XTrail is more truck like in the way it drives, comparatively.

SumoDog68 · 28-04-2012, 09:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nic85

This line lends me to believe you haven't driven an ASX. They're very soft riding and very comfortable over bumps. They ride a lot softer than Tiguan, SX4, CX7 and ix35, to name a few. The XTrail is more truck like in the way it drives, comparatively.

I hope you sell a few ASXs and Outlanders today :-)

My32Doors · 27-04-2012, 08:12 PM

One word -nissan. Never buy another one.

WILDB · 27-04-2012, 08:25 PM

My parents own one, it's been a reasonably good car but did have some major issues early on. The gearbox and transfer case were replaced at the first service due to Nissan grossly under filling them and the PDI at the selling dealer not picking it up.

Since then it's been pretty good with only a couple of minor things. They have a manual diesel and it goes pretty well for what it is and gets excellent economy.

Nic85 · 28-04-2012, 10:14 AM

I own one, I don't work for Mitsubishi,

.

I'm just talking from my personal experience. The missus and I test drove a heap of cars before we decided on the ASX. It's a great car but doesn't suit everyone.

I just mentioned it for the OP to look at. It might be too small for his needs, but it's maybe a car he didn't think about before. That's all.

SumoDog68 · 28-04-2012, 12:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nic85

I own one, I don't work for Mitsubishi,

.

I'm just talking from my personal experience. The missus and I test drove a heap of cars before we decided on the ASX. It's a great car but doesn't suit everyone.

I just mentioned it for the OP to look at. It might be too small for his needs, but it's maybe a car he didn't think about before. That's all.

That is ok Nic85 - it is a friendly discussion - i dont think ASX would be a bad purchase -we have driven most small SUV but i might of mixed it up with ix35 as far as ride harshness goes , it was a while ago...

MAGPIE · 28-04-2012, 01:17 PM

I would go with your original choice

Bossxr8 · 28-04-2012, 02:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nic85

I own one, I don't work for Mitsubishi,

.

I'm just talking from my personal experience. The missus and I test drove a heap of cars before we decided on the ASX. It's a great car but doesn't suit everyone.

I just mentioned it for the OP to look at. It might be too small for his needs, but it's maybe a car he didn't think about before. That's all.

Have you ever owned a Ford, or even made one single comment on this forum in a positive light about a Ford? Every post you make praises vehicles from other manufacturers, makes me wonder why you are a member here thats all.

Nic85 · 28-04-2012, 04:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bossxr8

Have you ever owned a Ford, or even made one single comment on this forum in a positive light about a Ford? Every post you make praises vehicles from other manufacturers, makes me wonder why you are a member here thats all.

Are you saying if I don't own a Ford that I'm not welcome to be on this forum?

Windsor342ci · 28-04-2012, 05:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nic85

Are you saying if I don't own a Ford that I'm not welcome to be on this forum?

I think your welcome if that matters. Regardless what your garage bares.
But if in the event you do carry on about Ford but praise all other makes, then with that in mind, no your not welcome.
Im not saying you are doing that, but if you are, then frankly your in the wrong neck of the woods.

Nic85 · 28-04-2012, 06:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CRYHSV

I think your welcome if that matters. Regardless what your garage bares.
But if in the event you do carry on about Ford but praise all other makes, then with that in mind, no your not welcome.
Im not saying you are doing that, but if you are, then frankly your in the wrong neck of the woods.

Fair dinkum. I suggested someone look at another car, and it's not a Ford.

GYRKIN GT · 28-04-2012, 05:34 PM

Hi Hally.

We bought our X-Trail TS manual diesel in December, 2009. Most of our mileage is done on the F3 between Hornsby and the Central Coast(NSW). It has now covered 46,000 kilometres.

Economy wise, it averages 6.7 litre/100k's. It is still on it's original tyres and there's probably another 5,000 to 8,000 kilometres of wear left.

Re Performance, the thing still amazes me. It's not super quick off the mark but it's no slouch either. Once it's up and running, with 360nM, it just rockets along. Don't know if you know the F3, but there's a couple of long significant hills. Just leave it in 6th, put the foot down a bit, and the thing just takes off. Never have to change down and the damn thing leaves a hell of a lot of other cars falling behind. It's brilliant.

The sole issue we've had with it was a slight water leak coming from the high central brake light in the rear door. This happened when the car was about 12 months old. Apparently, this was a common fault involving the original rubber gasket perishing. Nissan replaced it immediately and no problems since.

There's one thing you need to be aware of. The diesel needs a good run every so often to burn the crap off the particle filter. If you're only in city traffic, the filter will clog and you'll get an warning light. We've never suffered the problem because it's on the F3 all the time. The problem is not specific to Nissan, its apparently common to all the new diesels.

Would we buy another diesel X-Trail? You betcha. In a heartbeat. As I said, it's been brilliant. Furthermore, and most importantly to us, it's saved us from using our GT for day to day driving.

Hope this helps

Bossxr8 · 29-04-2012, 10:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nic85

Are you saying if I don't own a Ford that I'm not welcome to be on this forum?

Not at all.

But i'm just curious why someone who seems to have zero interest in Fords in any way is on a Ford enthusiast site thats all.

IceValk85 · 29-04-2012, 02:28 PM

great opportunity to wring a bargain out of the dealer on the current model then if a new ones coming!

Hally · 29-04-2012, 05:25 PM

Ice,

Actually not a lot of stock in the model I want, especially in a colour I like. A couple of dealers have confirmed list pricing remains the same with the updated model. It is only a minor update with no exterior changes.

XR Martin · 29-04-2012, 10:35 PM

They handle pretty crap and the factory tyres are ordinary.
I missed a turn off the highway in one a little while ago and turned a little late and fast, there was also a little gravel in the middle of the intersection. Anyway it understeered big time and I was certianly doing some sphincter puckering.
My fault? Probably, but if you drive like any other vehicle it can catch you out.

Oh and it was in a petrol one, a heavier diesel one would be even worse?